A Summary of Chronic
Fatigue Syndrome and Its Classification
in the International Classification of Diseases
Prepared by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
National Center for Health Statistics, Office of the Center Director, Data
Policy and Standards
March 2001
This document provides a summary of the classification of Chronic Fatigue
Syndrome in the
International Classification of Diseases, ninth and tenth revisions, and their
clinical
modifications.
ICD-9
The International Classification of Diseases, ninth revision (ICD-9), was
published by the World
Health Organization (WHO) in 1975. WHO did not make revisions to the
classification between
major updates, which usually occurred every ten years. The term “chronic fatigue
syndrome” did
not have a specific code in ICD-9 nor did the term appear in the alphabetic
index of ICD-9. The
only entry in the alphabetic index of the ICD-9 was “Syndrome, fatigue” and
referenced code
300.5, Neurasthenia, a condition classified in Chapter V, Mental disorders.
The term “benign myalgic encephalomyelitis” appears in the alphabetic index and
references
code 323.9, Encephalitis of unspecified cause. The code 323.9 did not include
reference to
postviral syndrome. The term “postviral syndrome” was classified to code 780.7,
Malaise and
fatigue, in Chapter 16, Symptoms, signs and ill-defined conditions.
It should be noted that while many terms are listed in the alphabetic index, all
of the terms may
not appear in the tabular list of the classification. This is a standard
convention of the ICD.
ICD-9-CM
For morbidity data the United States uses the International Classification of
Diseases, ninth
revision, clinical modification (ICD-9-CM), a clinical modification of ICD-9.
ICD-9-CM has
been used in the United States since 1979 and has an annual update process that
has been in place
since 1985. The update process begins with the convening of the public forum,
ICD-9-CM
Coordination and Maintenance Committee. Proposals to modify the classification
are presented
and discussed during these public meetings. Information about future meetings of
the ICD-9-CM
Coordination and Maintenance Committee may be found on the NCHS website at
http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/about/otheract/icd9/maint/maint.htm. In 1990, a
recommendation to
create a specific code for chronic fatigue syndrome was presented. At that time,
there was no
consensus about the etiology of the syndrome, which is needed to accurately
classify a condition
in the ICD. A new code could not be created because of this problem; however, a
modification
to the alphabetic index was made to direct users of the classification to code
780.7, Malaise and
fatigue. This is the same code used to identify cases of postviral syndrome.
This change became
effective October 1, 1991.
In 1998, subcategory 780.7 was expanded to include new five-digit codes. The new
codes created
included code 780.71, Chronic fatigue syndrome. The placement of this condition
in this
category was consistent with the WHO version of ICD-9 and with its placement
within ICD-9-CM.
ICD-10
WHO published ICD-10 in 1992 and included many modifications, among them
relocation of
some diagnoses to different chapters within the classification. WHO created a
new category
G93, Other disorders of brain, in Chapter VI, Diseases of the Nervous System,
and created a new
code G93.3, Postviral fatigue syndrome, a condition which was previously in the
symptom
chapter of ICD-9. WHO also moved benign myalgic encephalomyelitis to the new
code G93.3.
The alphabetic index contains other terms, such as chronic fatigue syndrome,
that WHO
considers synonymous or clinically similar.
Changes made in ICD-10 are unique to that version of the classification and not
retrospectively
applied to previous revisions of the ICD. Therefore, any changes in ICD-10 such
as the creation
of new categories or relocation of conditions from one chapter to another are
not retroactively
added to ICD-9 or ICD-9-CM.
ICD-10-CM
In keeping with the placement in the ICD-10, chronic fatigue syndrome (and its
synonymous
terms) will remain at G93.3 in ICD-10-CM.
While it appears most appropriate to classify chronic fatigue syndrome in
ICD-10-CM in the
same way that it is classified in ICD-10, this placement is not without problems.
The primary
concern with the current WHO placement in ICD-10 has been that the abnormalities
of the brain
in chronic fatigue syndrome patients most often cited in the literature are not
found in all chronic
fatigue syndrome patients. While chronic fatigue syndrome may be a heterogeneous
group of
disorders, some but not all are neurological in nature. Likewise, not all
patients have
experienced a viral infection prior to being diagnosed with chronic fatigue
syndrome, nor are
immune system anomalies universally found. Also of potential concern is the
similarity between
the type of neurological findings in chronic fatigue syndrome and in depression,
which is a
psychiatric disorder. Involvement of multiple systems has complicated the
classification of
chronic fatigue syndrome.
It should be noted that issues related to reimbursement have not been a factor
in deliberations
regarding placement of chronic fatigue syndrome in ICD. Modifications to
ICD-9-CM (the
classification currently in use) and in ICD-10-CM, its intended replacement, are
based on
relevant clinical information and adherence to the structure and conventions of
the ICD. relevant clinical information and adherence to the structure and
conventions of the ICD. The decision of third party payers regarding their
coverage and reimbursement policies are independent of the decisions regarding
modification of the classification.